The Moon’s origin story doesn’t add up

From Howtown.

Visit https://hensonshaving.com/howtown or use code ‘howtown’ to receive 100 free blades with the purchase of a razor. (Ensure both products are in the cart for the code to take effect.)

Source list: https://docs.google.com/document/d/15Nd8hwKR7-Ysfq5DEhPGbyMLzViDa17iSCQlA_Wdqkg/edit?usp=sharing

To support independent science journalism and get bonus content …
JOIN OUR PATREON: https://www.patreon.com/Howtown

Here are some of the wonderful people on who support this channel through our Patreon Town Council:

Bev Fong
Sean Barrett
Mike Purvis
Jon Hewett
Albychen
Aatish Bhatia
avaren
Evan Hass
Mark Tinker
L.A. O’Connor
Marcos Huerta
Joaquim Salles
Sam Gaty
Parag Mallick
Edgar Sutawika
Tim Davey
Navneet
Pedro ZM
Martin Weeks
Dimi
Bryce Golden-Chen
Estelle Caswell
Gregory Laborde
Yash Murthy
martin david
Matthew Stvartak
Garret Wates
Slightly Suspicious Mind
Kellyn Lorentzen-Goler
omg.science
Duncan Stannett
Keith England
Jocelyn Tabancay Duffy
Casey Schatz
Mark McCreary
Jonathan McCabe
Branden Ushjima
Esh Tatla
Wookiee Henderson
Frances Haugen
Gilbo Jiménez
Roy Lara
Kai Tze
Melanie Halley
Archie Stonehill
Ed Martini
Jose Zaragoza Jr
Jamieson Urquhart
Bogdan

How do we know where the moon came from? In this episode, Howtown dives into the giant impact hypothesis (the least bad theory of lunar origin) and the growing evidence that the story of Theia may be more complicated than the textbook version. We explore how scientists measure the Moon’s distance, mass, and angular momentum, why Earth’s Moon is so unusually large compared with other moons in the solar system, and how Apollo moon rocks transformed the debate over the origin of the Moon. Along the way, we unpack Robin Canup’s simulations, synestia and multiple-impact, evection resonance, and the “isotope crisis”: why Moon rocks are chemically almost identical to Earth despite models suggesting the Moon should be made mostly from an impactor. From lunar eclipses and amateur astronomy to Apollo samples, South Pole missions, Theia, Artemis, Chang’e, and the search for mantle rocks, this is a deep look at moon formation, planetary science, and how scientists reconstruct what happened more than 4 billion years ago.

Chapters:
00:00 intro
01:04 where is the moon
02:43 the moon is weird
04:20 4 hypotheses
06:08 razors for sale
07:29 the moon rocks
09:45 hartmann’s hawaii hypothesis
12:07 an inconvenient simulation
13:14 isotope crisis!
15:20 join patreon!!
15:30 messier solutions
18:20 back to venus
18:38 back to the moon
19:12 anthropic principle
20:27 love, howtown